“Some might conclude that this loaf could have used awhile longer in the oven. But that would be wrong; it is already overcooked. The most expert care in preparation cannot redeem a bad recipe. The sum of all the Court’s nonspecific hand-waving is that this law is invalid (maybe on equal-protection grounds, maybe on substantive-due-process grounds, and perhaps with some amorphous federalism component playing a role) because it is motivated by a “‘bare . . . desire to harm’” couples in same-sex marriages.”
-- Justice Scalia's dissent in UNITED STATES v. WINDSOR which ruled the Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional
Quote Last Modifed: 6/26/2013 7:10:48 PM
Database Dated : 11/20/2025 8:43:47 PM
Database Dated : 11/20/2025 8:43:47 PM